Wine Shop

Thief Wine's retail shop has more than 500 different distinctive and eclectic wines from around the world, ranging from $7 to the top end of the market. Our focus is on smaller, artisanal producers who are the best at what they do, offering you wines of exceptional quality and value. There will be plenty of labels you'll be familiar with, but many that are awaiting your discovery - we've got both classic wines from classic regions and new producers from exciting areas on the rise. We're happy to answer any questions you might have - we selected these wines because we believe in them and want to share them with you, so just ask. Whatever region or varietal you could possibly want, whether you want a wine to lay down in your cellar or to enjoy with dinner that night, we've got your taste!

We're also happy to special-order anything for you, as little as one bottle. If it's available in the state of Wisconsin, we'll get it for you, often by the next day.

Thief Wine offers 10% off purchases of 12 or more bottles; additionally, enroll in our free Customer Rewards Program - when your regularly priced retail wine purchases add up to $200, you'll automatically receive $15 off your next purchase! (Plus, we can keep track of your wine history, so if you come in wondering which bottle you bought a couple of months ago, we can find it instantly.)

We also feature curbside pick-up - buy your wine at any time during the day, give us a call when you're driving home and on your way, and we'll have it ready for you outside on St. Paul Avenue as you pull up.

Wine Shop


Wine Shop